I Baked With a Lodge Combo Cooker vs a Regular Dutch Oven for 30 Days

For months, I baked sourdough in a hand-me-down enameled Dutch oven. The results were fine — decent ear, decent crust — but I kept seeing stunning open crumb shots online. People credited their baking vessel. That sent me deep into a Lodge combo cooker sourdough comparison rabbit hole, and honestly, I came out the other side a convert. This post covers 30 full days of side-by-side baking so you can skip the guesswork I went through.

My biggest frustration was steam management. Every time I lifted the lid of my Dutch oven to check the bake, steam escaped fast. The heavy lid also made loading my shaped loaf a real fumble. I’d preshape, proof, then essentially drop the dough in from a height. More than once, I deflated a beautifully proofed boule. Something had to change.

I started paying closer attention to how other home bakers were loading their loaves. Most of the ones getting consistent results were using a combo cooker — where the shallow skillet acts as the base and the deeper pot drops down as a lid. That inverted setup looked like a game changer for scoring and loading. So I decided to test it properly, back to back, for a full month.

The Combo Cooker That Finally Let Me Control My Steam

Steam management was my biggest frustration with that hand-me-down Dutch oven—every time I lifted the lid to check color, precious moisture escaped unevenly, leaving me with flat, unpredictable crusts. The Lodge combo cooker’s separate skillet lid changed that completely, giving me actual control over when and how steam vents during the bake.

What works

• The skillet-as-lid design lets you tilt it open just enough to peek at oven spring and crust color without losing all your steam at once—I went from guessing to actually seeing what’s happening in the final minutes.
• Cast iron holds heat so aggressively that even after I open that skillet lid, the bottom of the loaf keeps getting blast-furnace heat, which means a thick, shattered crust every single time.
• The 3.2-quart capacity is tight for a full-size boule, which forces the dough to expand upward instead of spreading out—accidentally creating more vertical ear than my previous setup ever did.

What doesn’t

• The pot is heavy enough that pulling it out mid-bake to adjust that skillet lid requires both hands and confidence—fumbling with oven mitts while your loaf is at peak spring is stressful.
• Cast iron takes forever to preheat (I’m talking 45+ minutes to really get it hot), which means your oven needs to run longer and your kitchen turns into a sauna on hot days.

I’ll admit I second-guessed this after the first bake when I over-tilted that skillet lid and lost steam faster than expected, but by day five I had the motion down to muscle memory. If you’re frustrated with unpredictable crusts and want real control over your bake environment, grab the Lodge Cast Iron Combo Cooker – PFAS-Free 2-in-1 3.2 Quart Deep Pot and 10.25 Inch Skillet Set.

This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.