Why Does My Starter Smell Like Acetone, Cheese, or Nail Polish? I Investigated So You Don’t Have To

Why Does My Starter Smell Like Acetone, Cheese, or Nail Polish? I Investigated So You Don't Have To

Why does your starter suddenly smell like acetone, and does that mean it’s dead? No — that sharp, nail-polish-remover scent is almost always fixable, not fatal, and I learned that lesson while hovering over Harold’s jar, one hand fanning the fumes away from my face, the other frantically typing “my sourdough starter smells like acetone” … Read more

Sourdough Starter Won’t Rise: My 3-Week Diagnosis Diary (And What Finally Fixed It)

Sourdough Starter Won't Rise: My 3-Week Diagnosis Diary (And What Finally Fixed It)

A brutal cold snap had locked onto my kitchen that January, and by day fourteen it had quietly exposed the real problem. The jar sitting on my counter looked like slightly lumpy paste — no bubbles, no dome, nothing that resembled life. Sourdough starter won’t rise, I typed into Google for what had to be … Read more

Is Sourdough Hooch Actually a Problem? A Quick FAQ

What Is Hooch? Why Your Starter Separates and Whether You Should Actually Worry

The lid barely cracked open before that sharp, boozy tang hit me — sitting right on top of my starter was a thin layer of grayish liquid I hadn’t seen before, pooled like something had gone wrong overnight. This was a starter I’d been babying for three months, and my brain immediately jumped to worst-case … Read more