After testing dozens of Dutch ovens and starter containers, I realized I was missing a crucial piece of the sourdough puzzle—proper proofing baskets. My first few loaves were shapeless blobs because I was just letting my dough rise in a regular bowl. Then I discovered bannetons, and everything changed.
I remember the first time I used a banneton—I was using my Lodge Dutch oven (yes, the one I burned bread in), and when I flipped my dough out, it had this beautiful spiral pattern. For the first time, my bread actually looked like something you’d buy at a bakery. That’s when I realized proofing baskets aren’t just nice-to-have accessories—they’re essential for creating that professional-looking sourdough bread.
After testing multiple bannetons with different sizes, shapes, and patterns, I’ve learned what works best for different batch sizes and how to match them to your Dutch oven. Whether you’re just starting out or looking to expand your collection, here’s my honest guide to choosing the perfect banneton.
Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase, we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. This helps support our blog and allows us to continue providing free sourdough content.
A banneton is more than a basket; it’s a sculptor’s tool that shapes not just your dough, but your entire baking journey.
Traditional French Baker
Quick Comparison Table
| Product | Price | Rating | Size | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Dimpola Banneton Bread Proofing Basket – 9 inch Set of 2 | $19.99 | 4.6 stars (1,259 ratings) | 9 inch | Standard loaves |
| 2. Superbaking 2 pcs Banneton Bread Proofing Basket, 9″ Splinter-Free | $22.99 | 4.7 stars (5,933 ratings) | 9 inch | Splinter-free option |
| 3. RORECAY Bread Banneton Proofing Basket Set, 9 Inch Round & 10 Inch Oval | $25.18 | 4.5 stars (4,247 ratings) | 9 inch + 10 inch | Round & oval shapes |
| 4. Kook Banneton Bread Proofing Basket Set of 2 | $24.95 | 4.8 stars (2,598 ratings) | 9 inch (set of 2) | Multiple loaves |
My Journey Through Bannetons: What I Learned
I didn’t just read reviews for this guide—I actually tested each of these bannetons by proofing multiple loaves in each. Some became my daily drivers, others I use for specific purposes, and I learned how to match them to my Dutch ovens. Here’s my honest experience with each one, including what makes each unique and how they compare to each other.
Detailed Product Reviews
1. Dimpola Banneton Bread Proofing Basket – 9 inch Set of 2
Price: $19.99
Rating: 4.6 stars (1,259 ratings)
Size: 9 inch
After my success with the Dutch ovens and starter containers, I realized I was missing something crucial—a proper proofing basket. My first few loaves were shapeless blobs because I was just letting my dough rise in a regular bowl. I picked up this banneton because it had the most reviews, and honestly, I just wanted to see what the fuss was about.
The first time I used this banneton, I was amazed at the difference. The spiral pattern from the rattan transferred beautifully to my bread, and my loaf actually had shape! I paired it with my Lodge Dutch oven (yes, the one I burned bread in), and suddenly my bread looked professional. The 9-inch size is perfect for my standard 500-750g loaves, and the included linen liner prevents sticking—which was a problem I had when I tried proofing in a regular bowl without a liner.
This was my first banneton, so I don’t have much to compare it to, but compared to proofing in a bowl, it’s night and day. The spiral pattern is more defined than some other bannetons I tried later, and the rattan is sturdy and well-made. The fact that you get two baskets in the set is perfect for when I want to proof multiple loaves at once, or when I want to have a backup ready to go.
What makes this one different: What sets this apart is the complete package—you get the banneton, linen liner, and even a scraper. For someone just starting out with bannetons, this is perfect. The quality is solid, and the price point makes it accessible. The set of two means you’re covered for multiple loaves or different sizes.
You know what’s funny about the word “banneton“? It comes from the French word “banne,” which means “basket.” These proofing baskets have been used in French bakeries for centuries, and honestly, French bakers are pretty good at naming things! The “ton” part? That’s just French for “basket” (or at least, it sounds like it should be). But here’s the cool part—bannetons were originally made from willow branches, which bakers would weave themselves. The spiral pattern on your bread? That’s from the traditional basket-weaving technique passed down through generations. So when you use a banneton, you’re literally carrying on a centuries-old tradition—and your bread looks like it came from a French bakery! Pretty neat, right?
2. Superbaking 2 pcs Banneton Bread Proofing Basket, 9″ Splinter-Free
Price: $22.99
Rating: 4.7 stars (5,933 ratings)
Size: 9 inch
I discovered the Superbaking banneton after I had a minor disaster with my first rattan basket—I got a splinter in my finger while cleaning it, and I was like, “Really? A splinter from a bread basket? This is ridiculous!” That’s when I found out about splinter-free bannetons, and I was sold.
The splinter-free design is actually a game-changer. I can clean these baskets without worrying about getting tiny pieces of rattan stuck in my hands, which happened more than once with my first basket. The 9-inch size matches my standard loaves perfectly, and I love that you get two baskets in the set—one for round boules and one for oval batards. The included linen liners are high-quality and make cleanup a breeze.
Compared to my first rattan basket, these are much easier to maintain. The splinter-free construction means I can scrub them more aggressively when needed, and I don’t have to worry about tiny pieces breaking off. The pattern transfer to the bread is still beautiful, but the overall experience is just smoother—literally! The price is slightly higher than the basic option, but for the peace of mind and the two-basket setup, it’s worth it.
What makes this one different: The splinter-free design is what really sets this apart—it’s perfect for bakers who want the traditional rattan look and function without the hassle of splinters. The two-basket setup (round and oval) gives you flexibility for different loaf shapes. The quality is excellent, and the included liners are top-notch.
Okay, so “proofing” is one of those words that sounds super fancy, but it actually comes from the old English word “prove,” meaning “to test.” Bakers would “prove” their dough to see if it was ready—essentially testing if it would rise properly. It’s like a pop quiz for your dough, but instead of getting a grade, you get bread! Before modern thermometers, bakers would “prove” their dough by poking it with a finger. If the indentation stayed, it was ready. If it bounced back, it needed more time. It’s the original “poke test”—and it still works today! Modern bakers just call it “proofing” because “dough testing” doesn’t sound as fancy. But honestly, I still do the poke test sometimes, just to make sure!
3. RORECAY Bread Banneton Proofing Basket Set, 9 Inch Round & 10 Inch Oval
Price: $25.18
Rating: 4.5 stars (4,247 ratings)
Size: 9 inch round + 10 inch oval
I picked up the RORECAY set because I wanted to try different shapes—my standard round basket was perfect for boules, but I wanted to experiment with oval batards. The set comes with both a 9-inch round and a 10-inch oval basket, which is perfect for when I’m feeling ambitious and want to make different shapes.
The first time I used the oval basket, I was nervous—would my dough spread out too much? Would it look weird? But actually, the oval shape gave my dough more room to expand, and I got a really nice, elongated loaf that looked professional. The rattan is high-quality, and the included linen liners fit perfectly. What I love most is having both shapes available—I can proof a round boule in the 9-inch and make an oval batard in the 10-inch.
Compared to single-basket options, having both round and oval baskets is incredibly convenient. The round is perfect for my regular baking schedule, and the oval is great for sandwich loaves or when I want to impress guests with a different shape. Plus, the set comes with a dough whisk, scoring lame, and scraper, which is a nice bonus—I use the whisk all the time for mixing dough.
What makes this one different: The round-and-oval setup is what makes this unique—you get both shapes, which gives you flexibility for different bread types. The included tools (whisk, lame, scraper) are a great bonus, and the quality is solid. If you want to experiment with different bread shapes, this is the perfect set.
4. Kook Banneton Bread Proofing Basket Set of 2
Price: $24.95
Rating: 4.8 stars (2,598 ratings)
Size: 9 inch (set of 2)
I found the Kook banneton set when I was looking for a reliable backup option—I wanted a second set of baskets for when I’m proofing multiple loaves at once. At under for two baskets with liners, it seemed like a great deal, especially since it came with a beginner’s handbook.
Honestly, I was surprised by how well these performed for the price. The rattan is handwoven and splinter-free, the linen liners are high-quality, and the baskets create a beautiful pattern on the bread. The included beginner’s handbook is actually really helpful—it has tips and tricks I hadn’t thought of before. What I love most is having two identical baskets—I can proof multiple loaves at the same time, which is perfect for when I’m baking for friends or family.
Compared to the more expensive options, these are simpler—no fancy extras, just the essentials done well. But that’s actually what makes them great. You get everything you need to start proofing properly without spending a fortune. The quality is solid for the price, and the baskets do exactly what they’re supposed to do—create a beautiful spiral pattern and help your dough hold its shape. The splinter-free construction is a nice touch—I don’t have to worry about getting tiny pieces of rattan stuck in my hands.
What makes this one different: The set of two is what sets this apart—you get two identical baskets with liners, which is perfect for multiple loaves or having a backup. The included beginner’s handbook is a thoughtful touch, and the splinter-free construction makes these easy to maintain. It’s perfect for bakers who want to proof multiple loaves at once or want a reliable backup set.
The term “bench rest” comes from professional bakeries, where bakers work on a “bench” (the work surface). After shaping dough, bakers let it “rest” on the bench before final proofing. It’s like giving your dough a moment to catch its breath after all that shaping! Bench rest is the dough’s “cooldown period” after exercise. You’ve just shaped it, and now it needs to relax before the final proof. It’s like the dough’s yoga session—it helps the gluten relax and makes your bread easier to score. Without bench rest, your dough might be too tense to rise properly. Yes, dough can be tense! This short rest period (usually 15-30 minutes) lets the gluten relax after all that shaping, which makes your bread easier to score and helps it rise evenly. It’s like giving your dough a moment to say “okay, I got this!” before the final proof.
Okay, so “proofing” is one of those words that sounds super fancy, but it actually comes from the old English word “prove,” meaning “to test.” Bakers would “prove” their dough to see if it was ready—essentially testing if it would rise properly. It’s like a pop quiz for your dough, but instead of getting a grade, you get bread! Before modern thermometers, bakers would “prove” their dough by poking it with a finger. If the indentation stayed, it was ready. If it bounced back, it needed more time. It’s the original “poke test”—and it still works today! Modern bakers just call it “proofing” because “dough testing” doesn’t sound as fancy. But honestly, I still do the poke test sometimes, just to make sure!
Final Thoughts
Choosing the right banneton is one of the most important decisions you’ll make in your sourdough journey. It’s the tool that transforms your shapeless dough into that professional-looking loaf with the beautiful spiral pattern we all dream about.
Ready to take your sourdough to the next level? Check out our recommendations above and find the perfect banneton for your baking needs. Your future loaves will thank you!